NUUBI
Back to Blog

Compliance vs. Security in Education Technology Vendor Review

· Nuubi Team

When a university evaluates a technology vendor, one of the first things it asks for is proof of compliance. That proof comes in three distinct kinds: an independent examination of the vendor’s controls, a review of the vendor’s stated privacy policies, and the vendor’s own answers to a questionnaire such as the HECVAT. Each is useful, and each can create false comfort when a reviewer assumes it covers more than it does.

Before asking a vendor for anything, check your institution’s procurement and risk policy, which may require a specific report for certain tools or data. Ask your institution which office owns the review. An instructor or instructional designer helps most by describing what the tool will do and what student data it will touch, and by sending the vendor’s documents to that office.

Independent Examinations Under SOC 2 and ISO/IEC 27001

A SOC 2 report is an examination by an independent CPA firm of a service organization’s controls, measured against the AICPA Trust Services Criteria. Security is always in scope, and a report can also cover Availability, Processing Integrity, Confidentiality, and Privacy. Vendors usually share these reports on request. A Type 1 report assesses the design of controls as of a specific date, while a Type 2 report also tests whether those controls operated effectively over a period.

If a vendor has a SOC 2 report, check these four things:

Note whether it is Type 1 or Type 2 and what period it covers, and whether that period is recent.

Confirm which products and services are in scope, including the specific product and AI features you are buying.

Look for subservice organizations, such as hosting providers, that are carved out of the examination, and ask what separate evidence covers them.

Read both the auditor’s overall opinion and, in a Type 2 report, any exceptions found in testing, since exceptions can appear alongside a clean opinion.

A SOC 2 report does not automatically establish coverage or assurance for changes made after its period. Suppose a vendor added an AI assistant that sends student questions to an outside model provider after the period ended. Ask whether the assistant is in scope, how the auditor or the vendor handled the change, and when it will be assessed.

ISO/IEC 27001 certification is a different kind of evidence. The standard addresses an information security management system, meaning the way an organization manages security risk. If a vendor says it is certified, check the certificate’s stated scope, which can cover only part of a business, and its validity dates.

1EdTech TrustEd Apps Certification and Rubrics

The 1EdTech TrustEd Apps Data Privacy Certification reviews what a vendor says in its policies. 1EdTech’s privacy team checks a product’s privacy policy, terms of service, advertising policy, AI policy, and related documents against its Data Privacy Rubric, and the vendor completes a self-assessment. The certification addresses privacy practices as stated in those policies and does not examine security controls.

If a vendor has it, confirm the seal in the TrustEd Apps Directory, since a logo on a vendor’s website is not confirmation, and check the validity period and that the certified product is the one you are buying. If not, ask the vendor directly who receives student data, whether it is used for advertising, how long it is kept, and which AI model provider is involved. 1EdTech also publishes a Data Privacy and Security Agreement template that can serve as a starting point for a contract.

Separately, 1EdTech reviews and publishes two vendor self-assessments under a product’s directory entry. The Security Practices Rubric covers security practices for course-level tools, and the Generative AI Data Rubric covers AI privacy disclosures, including whether a product’s AI is built in-house or comes from a third party. Only 1EdTech members can see the detailed results, so if your institution is not a member, ask the vendor for a copy, and check when each was completed and whether the answers point to evidence.

The HECVAT as the Common Questionnaire for Vendor Review

The Higher Education Community Vendor Assessment Toolkit (HECVAT) is a questionnaire designed by higher education leaders in collaboration with EDUCAUSE, Internet2, and REN-ISAC. A vendor completes it to describe its cybersecurity, privacy, IT accessibility, and compliance practices, and the institution reviews the answers. Those answers are self-attested, so a completed HECVAT is not a certification, an audit, or an examination, and EDUCAUSE does not collect completed copies.

The workbook’s evaluation tabs score each answer against a compliant response chosen by the volunteers who wrote the questions, and asterisked critical questions carry the most weight. Reviewers can include or exclude categories, override compliance and importance, mark items as non-negotiable, and add notes. EDUCAUSE says the score is not complete until the institution evaluates the answers against its own policies and appetite for risk, so a score on its own is not a verdict. HECVAT 4 combines the former Full, Lite, and On-Premise versions into one file, includes questions on privacy and AI, and allows a lighter review of only the asterisked questions.

The HECVAT gives every vendor the same set of questions, and evidence such as a SOC 2 Type 2 report, an ISO/IEC 27001 certificate, or a 1EdTech certification can support the answers. EDUCAUSE notes that most colleges and universities will accept a recent SOC 2 Type 2 report as a thorough, authoritative review by an objective third-party auditor, that many will consider alternate documentation such as the CAIQ questionnaire, and that sales literature does not replace those security-focused reviews. A HECVAT and a SOC 2 report are different kinds of evidence, so the useful test for each HECVAT answer is whether it cites something you can check, such as a report, certificate, policy, or test summary.

If a vendor has a completed HECVAT, confirm that it covers the product you are buying, that it is version 4.x, and that it was completed within about the last year, since EDUCAUSE asks vendors to update it at least once per year. Then ask the office that owns the review which answers it wants confirmed. If a vendor does not have one, your institution can ask it to complete one.

Evidence From Vendors Without a SOC 2 Report

A missing SOC 2 report leaves a gap in evidence without proving that a vendor’s security is weak. If your institution’s policy requires the report, ask the office that owns the review whether it will consider other evidence. Where the policy does not require it, a vendor can describe its practices in a completed HECVAT, the form universities already use, and support those answers with recent penetration test summaries, an incident response plan, a data processing agreement, its subprocessor list, and written answers to the questions below. This evidence provides a different kind of assurance from an independent examination, so the reviewer still decides whether it is enough, and the vendor’s obligations belong in the contract.

Supply Chain and AI Model Provider Risk

Many companies rely on other vendors for hosting, file transfer, and security monitoring, and a failure at one of those suppliers can affect the customers that depend on it. The 2023 MOVEit file transfer breach is a well-known example of supplier risk, in which attackers went through a widely used tool to reach many organizations that depended on it. The National Student Clearinghouse said nearly 900 colleges were affected by that breach, according to its filings with the California attorney general’s office, as reported by Higher Ed Dive. A hosting provider’s SOC 2 report or ISO/IEC 27001 certificate covers the provider, so the vendor’s own controls still need their own evidence.

The same reasoning applies to the AI model provider behind a tool. Ask which provider the tool uses, what student data reaches it, under what terms, and what evidence covers that provider’s service. A vendor’s own report may leave the model provider out of scope, and a good vendor will say so plainly.

Security Questions for Education Technology Vendors

Education technology handles information about students, including their questions, their drafts, their grades, and sometimes their struggles. A vendor that can show a credential but cannot explain what happens to student data has not given you the answer you need, so these questions apply whether or not a vendor holds one:

Which products, services, and hosting environments does each report or certification cover, and what does it exclude?

What has changed since the review period, such as new features, new AI capabilities, or new subprocessors?

Which other companies, such as hosting providers or AI model providers, receive student data, and under what terms?

Where is student data stored, who can access it, and how long is it kept?

What happens if something goes wrong, and how and when will you be told?

Can the institution have its data deleted or returned when the contract ends?

A substantive answer is specific and written down. Asked about scope, a vendor might name its most recent report, the period it covers, the products included, any features or subprocessors left out, and when those will be reviewed. That gives you something to file and check later, and a vague answer, or one given only on a call, tells you something too.

For more on how AI tools should protect students, see Beyond the Model: AI Privacy, Safety, and Security for Students, and for detailed data-handling questions, see FERPA Questions for Reviewers of AI Tools That Handle Student Data.

Institutional Responsibility After Vendor Review

Compliance evidence has real value. It documents controls and gives reviewers a shared starting point. The trouble comes when either side treats it as the whole job. Vendor evidence is one input alongside your own questions, the office that owns the review, and your sense of the failure modes that worry you most. Access deserves the same attention, since a course assistant that reads course materials has no reason to see the gradebook.

Responsibility for students’ data stays with the institution after the contract is signed, so these questions are worth asking again at renewal and whenever a vendor adds a major feature. If you are evaluating an AI-integrated tool for a course, including Nuubi, ask them and expect written answers you can check.